Evaluation of Sweet Corn Cultivars at Ames Plantation in 2003

Jim E. Wyatt, Marshall C. Smith, and Emily W. Gatch

Interpretative Summary

Su and sh2 sweet corn hybrids were tested at Ames Plantation in a replicated study in 2003. Of the su types, ‘Excalibur’ had the highest percentage of kernels {(kernel wt ÷ total ear wt)*100} when adjusted for moisture content, and the highest yield of cut corn. ‘Max’ had the highest yield of cut corn, ears per acre, ear weight, and one of the highest kernel moisture contents of the sh2 types.

Materials and Methods

Eight su and ten sh2-type sweet corn hybrids adapted primarily for processing were grown in two separated plantings in 2003. The two plantings were isolated by time as well as distance to prevent cross-pollination between the two types. The su hybrids were planted April 10 and the sh2 hybrids were planted May 10, 2003, at Ames Plantation.

Experimental design of each study was a randomized complete block with four replications. Individual plots were single rows, 20 feet long and 3.3 feet apart. Plant spacing within plots was about 6-8 inches. Before planting, 600 lbs of 15-15-15 fertilizer and 4 quarts of Diazinon insecticide per acre were broadcast and incorporated. A sidedress application of ammonium nitrate was applied to supply 45 pounds of nitrogen per acre when corn was 12 to 18 inches high. Supplemental water was applied as needed with an overhead irrigation system. Production practices followed UT recommendations for sweet corn in Tennessee.

Ear heights were measured on four plants in each plot from the soil surface to the base of the top ear. A rating was made on the second planting for amount of lodging since a wind event caused some stalks to be blown down. Plots in the first planting were harvested July 3 through 9 and in the second planting July 23 through 28. Ears were harvested when kernel moisture was 72-80%. Data collected included total weight of ears, weight of a sample of five ears from each plot, ear length and diameter (5 ears), weight of cut corn (5 ears), and dry weight of cut corn from five ears. These data were used to calculate number of ears/acre, ear yield in tons/acre, percent kernel moisture, percent kernels adjusted to 72% moisture, and yield of cut corn per acre.

Data were converted to per-acre yields and subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) using appropriate SAS procedures. Means were separated using Duncan’s multiple range tests at P#0.05 where applicable.

Results and Discussion

su-Type Hybrids

Time from planting to harvest ranged from 80 to 86 days for su hybrids (Table 1). Those that matured at 80 and 81 days were not among the highest yielding five hybrids in the test. Highest yielding hybrids matured in 84 to 86 days. ‘Esquire’ and ‘RX 8490549’ produced the most ears per acre and ‘RX 8490549’ produced the highest tonnage of ears. ‘XP 08715864’ had significantly lower yields in terms of tonnage, possibly because of immaturity since it had also had the highest percentage of kernel moisture. All of the hybrids could probably have been harvested one to two days later and still been within the desired kernel moisture range.

Table 1. April 10, 2003, planting of su (sugary) sweet corn hybrids at Ames Plantation, spring, 2003.

 

 

Cultivar/Hybrid

 

 

Source

 

Days to harvest

 

Ears/A

(doz)

 

Ear wt

(tons/A)

Kernel

moisturez

(%)

8452067

Seminis

82dy

2069ab

7.9a

76.6bc

XP 08715864

Seminis

80e

1538d

5.8b

80.6a

SVR08302418

Seminis

81d

1797c

7.4a

77.8b

Esquire

Seminis

84c

2137a

7.6a

78.1b

RX 8490549

Seminis

86a

2110a

8.5a

74.9cd

Excalibur

Harris Moran

84c

2028abc

7.4a

75.7c

Legacy

Harris Moran

85b

1838bc

7.8a

75.6c

GH 2547

Syngenta

86a

1906abc

7.8a

73.4d

zMoisture content of kernels cut from five randomly selected ears

yMeans in columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different, Duncan’s multiple range test, (P#0.05).

Small but significant differences were found between hybrids for ear diameter and length (Table 2). Ear diameter may be more important in a processing sweet corn than ear length, since two of the hybrids with smaller ear diameters also had the lowest yield of cut corn. ‘Excalibur’ had the highest percentage of kernels {(kernel wt ÷ total ear wt)*100} when adjusted for moisture content, and the highest yield of cut corn.

Table 2. April 10, 2003, planting of su (sugary) sweet corn hybrids at Ames Plantation, spring, 2003.

 

 

Cultivar/Hybrid

Ear

diameter

(inches)

Ear

length

(inches)

Ear

height

(inches)z

 

Percent

kernels

Percent

kernels

(adjusted)y

Cut

corn

(lbs/A)x

8452067

2.23aw

8.4ab

29.0a

29.3de

27.6ef

5281abc

XP 08715864

2.08bc

8.5a

24.7cd

37.3a

33.3abc

4586cd

SVR08302418

2.23a

8.4ab

25.5bcd

27.7e

25.7f

3978d

Esquire

2.03c

8.4ab

28.5ab

32.9bc

30.3de

5457abc

RX 8490549

2.18a

8.6a

28.8a

33.0bc

31.6bcd

5861ab

Excalibur

2.18a

8.1bc

27.4abc

36.6a

34.8a

5944a

Legacy

2.20a

8.7a

28.8a

35.5ab

33.8ab

5818ab

GH 2547

2.05c

7.9c

29.5a

31.7cd

31.1cd

4974bc

zInches from soil to base of top ear

yKernel moisture adjusted to 72%

xBased on number of calculated ears per acre and percent kernels cut from five randomly selected ears.

wMeans in columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different, Duncan’s multiple range test, (P#0.05).

sh2-Type Hybrids

Time from planting to harvest ranged from 74 to 79 days for sh2 hybrids (Table 3). The shorter maturity of sh2 types is probably due to warmer temperatures and faster heat unit accumulation of the later planting. ‘Max’ had the highest yield of ears per acre, the highest ear weight, and one of the highest kernel moisture contents of the sh2 types. Lodging was a problem in the second planting because of a rain storm accompanied by high winds. Hybrids which had the least amount of lodging were ‘SVR08705770’ and ‘EX 08716636’.

Table 3. May 10, 2003, planting of sh2 (shrunken 2) sweet corn hybrids at Ames Plantation.

 

Cultivar/Hybrid

 

Source

 

Days to

harvest

 

Ears/A

(doz)

 

Ear wt

(tons/A)

Kernel

moisturez

(%)

Lodging

scorey

EX 08716636

Seminis

79ax

1075e

4.1e

75.3d

8e

Challenger

Seminis

74e

1443de

6.0de

77.9bc

78a

XP 4814737

Seminis

77b

1906bc

7.0bcd

76.3d

30cde

SVR08705770

Seminis

79a

1429de

5.7de

75.4d

4e

9381178

Seminis

77b

1647cd

6.9cd

78.0bc

24de

Max

Harris Moran

75d

2368a

9.8a

79.3a

40bcd

Rustler

Harris Moran

75d

1892bc

8.3abc

78.9ab

65ab

Ice Queen

Harris Moran

74e

1756bcd

7.5bcd

76.1d

43bcd

GSS 8388

Syngenta

76c

2028abc

7.7bcd

79.4a

56abc

GSS 8357

Syngenta

76c

2110ab

9.0ab

77.4

55abc

zMoisture content of kernels cut from five randomly selected ears

yPercent of stalks lodged

xMeans in columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different, Duncan’s multiple range test, (P#0.05).

The sh2 hybrid with the largest ears (both diameter and length) was ‘GSS 8357’ which did not differ significantly from ‘9381178’ and ‘Max’ which had the highest percentage kernels and the highest yield of cut corn, respectively (Table 4).

Overall yields tended to be higher in the sh2 planting compared to the su planting. This difference is probably due to growing conditions (temperature, moisture, fertility) rather than differences between types.

Table 4. May 10, 2003, planting of sh2 (shrunken 2) sweet corn hybrids at Ames Plantation.

Cultivar/Hybrid

Ear

diameter

(inches)

Ear

length

(inches)

Ear

height

(inches)z

 

Percent

kernels

Percent

kernels

(adjusted)y

Cut

corn

(lbs/A)x

EX 08716636

2.05dw

8.2b

22.5e

35.2de

33.7c

2868f

Challenger

2.08cd

8.7a

23.5e

37.2cd

34.4c

4402e

XP 4814737

2.08cd

8.4ab

28.9bc

41.2bc

38.9ab

6453cd

SVR08705770

2.13a-d

8.3ab

32.5a

40.8bc

39.0ab

4845de

9381178

2.20ab

8.2b

23.3e

45.6a

42.1a

6411cd

Max

2.18abc

8.3ab

26.5cd

40.7bc

37.0bc

8514a

Rustler

2.10bcd

8.4ab

27.9bc

40.5bc

37.0bc

6690bc

Ice Queen

2.18abc

8.3ab

24.8de

31.8e

30.0d

4973de

GSS 8388

2.08cd

8.4ab

30.4ab

43.2ab

39.3ab

7043abc

GSS 8357

2.23a

8.7a

29.3b

43.3ab

40.2ab

8134ab

zInches from soil to base of top ear

yKernel moisture adjusted to 72%

xBased on number of calculated ears per acre and percent kernels cut from five randomly selected ears.

wMeans in columns followed by the same letter are not significantly different, Duncan’s multiple range test, (P#0.05).

 

Email all comments and suggestions to ghonea@utk.edu
Copyright © 1999 by The University of Tennessee. All rights reserved.

This research represents one season's data and does not constitute recommendations.  After sufficient data is collected over the appropriate number of seasons, final recommendations will be made through research and extension publications.